El Nino and The Spring Predictability Barrier Mar 3, 2017

While you can’t set your watch to El Niño or La Niña because it occurs irregularly and sometimes with little warning, when one does emerge it is strongly linked to the calendar month. Typically, events peak during the Northern Hemisphere winter and then weaken or disappear during the spring or summer. In part because ENSO is transitioning, the spring is a difficult time to predict whether the upcoming winter will be El Niño, La Niña, or neutral conditions. This has been called the spring predictability barrier and like most barriers it presents additional challenges to get beyond. Currently, there is a hint of a forecast of a future El Niño but the barrier makes it difficult to be too confident in the predictions.

That makes this a nice time to review why we are able to predict ENSO at all and what aspects are particularly challenging to predict. Unlike weather prediction, where we rarely have to account for changes in the ocean, in ENSO prediction we have to forecast both the slower, more predictable changes in the tropical Pacific Ocean and the faster, less predictable movements of the atmosphere above it. At the risk of spoiling my punch line, during the spring, the starting conditions of the ocean provide less guidance than at other times of year and they are much less helpful for forecasting El Niño events than La Niña events.

Predicting La Niña: Cool down the Ocean
While the focus is often on El Niño, research has suggested that it’s sibling, La Niña, is more predictable than El Niño. To understand this, we turn to one theoretical basis for ENSO, the recharge oscillator. The recharge oscillator says warmer sea surface temperatures (SST) in the eastern Pacific Ocean along the equator weaken the winds and cause poleward movement of warm ocean water. This effect can be seen from the surface down to ~1000 feet below the surface of the ocean. As warmer ocean waters shift away from the equator, cooler water upwells from the deeper ocean, creating a deficit of Warm Water Volume on the equator and can trigger a La Niña event. Arguably, we saw this happen over the last year as we transitioned from a mammoth El Niño event to the weak La Niña conditions of the past several months.

Previous research indicates warm water volume at the equator precede SSTs by 6-9 months. From this one might think that warm water volume should be as good of a sign in predicting El Niño as La Niña. But the figure below tells us a different story. The horizontal x-axis shows that negative values of springtime warm water volume (numbers less than zero) are often related to La Niña-levels of cooling (blue dots) in the Niño-3.4 SST region, which is shown on the vertical y-axis. However, the opposite situation is not as true: positive anomalies in warm water volume do not confidently result in an El Niño event (red dots).

The Warm Water Volume anomaly during February-April compared against Niño-3.4 sea surface temperature (SST) during the following November-January. Large negative values of Warm Water Volume anomalies almost always lead to a La Niña event. However, large positive Warm Water Volume anomalies do not lead to El Niño events. For SST data, OISST is used. Warm Water Volume comes from the PMEL analysis (http://www.pmel.noaa.gov/elnino/upper-ocean-heat-content-and-enso). Figure provided by Aaron Levine and modified by Climate.gov.

Predicting El Niño: Warm up the Ocean and Turn On the Noise
So, what makes warm water volume a worse indicator for El Niño events than La Niña events? Simply put, plain old weather over the equatorial Pacific Ocean greatly complicates the picture.

To understand how the weather impacts ENSO, let’s start by thinking about what happens when we blow across a pan of hot water. First, the water cools where we are blowing. Second, the water stacks up on the side of the pan opposite of where we are blowing.

Now to apply this to the tropical Pacific Ocean, where the winds normally blow from east to west, which piles up warm water in the western Pacific (see normal/neutral conditions of the Walker circulation here). Prior to the possible onset of El Niño, we want to see whether the normal winds weaken—a westerly anomaly—and not all at once, but in a series of successive pulses. If strong enough, these Westerly Wind Bursts can simultaneously cool the waters in the extreme western Pacific and allow the warm waters in the western Pacific to slide east. The increase in warm water volume that accompanies these westerly wind bursts can increase the potential for, but not guarantee, an El Niño event.

In fact, expansion of the warm surface waters to the eastern Pacific can also create conditions where more westerly wind bursts will occur! A westerly wind burst makes a second one more likely to occur than the original one (scientists call this “state-dependent noise forcing,” a term that would make you the most popular guest at your next dinner party (4)). This Weather Noise (a measure of winds- for more details see the Methodology section below) results in a larger range of possible outcomes that depends on what happens during the spring and summer months. For example, the ENSO evolution in spring and summer of 2014 was very different from that of 2015 despite very similar starting conditions in the ocean.

Compare the similarities between subsurface (top 300 meters of the ocean) warm water volume in spring 2014 (left) and 2015 (right). Despite the similarities, 2014’s impressive warm anomaly failed to evolve into El Niño, while 2015’s slightly smaller anomaly did. NOAA Climate.gov images based on Climate Prediction Center data. large versions 2014 | 2015

The figure below shows that the influence of weather noise over the March-October time period is very important to the development of El Niño events (red dots). In particular, notice how the red dots cluster on the positive side of the weather noise. This means one needs to see more westerly winds in order to obtain El Niño during the upcoming winter. If there are more easterly winds during March-October (negative values of weather noise), then El Niño does not historically develop regardless of whether there is a deep pool of warm water beneath the surface. On the other hand, the La Niña events (blue dots) occur as often with positive weather noise as negative weather noise.

The Weather Noise forcing from March-October compared against Niño-3.4 sea surface temperature (SST) during the following November-January. The weather noise forcing is an important part of El Niño events, but it is not that important of a component for any other year. The weather noise is calculated from GODAS zonal wind stress using the formula for τR from Levine and Jin 2017. Figure provided by Aaron Levine and modified by Climate.gov.

So, the existence of a large volume of warm water below the surface in the spring isn’t, by itself, a reliable predictor the El Niño will develop because the atmosphere has to help out by relaxing the prevailing winds; and when or if those westerly wind bursts will happen isn’t predictable months in advance.

But why isn’t the same true for La Niña? To a large extent, that takes us back to the recharge oscillator theory mentioned above (and that Michelle blogged about before). According to that theory, as warm surface water from a decaying El Niño drains north and south away from the equator cold water from deeper in the ocean wells up to replace it. These siphoning currents—outflow followed by upwelling—create a strong momentum toward La Niña that is hard to interrupt. That momentum makes weather noise less significant, and it makes deficits of warm water volume in the spring a more reliable predictor that La Niña will develop.

All of that is great, but what does it say about the upcoming winter?
Some model predictions indicate an El Niño event may happen this coming winter. Let’s evaluate these simple ideas in light of that prediction. Currently, the warm water volume anomaly is nearly zero and the SST anomaly is increasing (becoming less negative). With spring time warm water volume anomalies near zero, we can more confidently state there is a smaller likelihood of a La Niña event happening. But, to be even more confident in a possible El Niño, we need to watch carefully what happens with the weather over the tropical Pacific during the spring and even into the summer. The upcoming months will be telling.

What we covered here is a simple framework, but these ideas help reinforce and give a physical basis for what the more complex seasonal climate forecast models are telling us. It is always comforting when the forecasts fit well with our understanding of ENSO predictability. And if (and when!) they don’t align, we see that as an opportunity to better our understanding of ENSO and improve our prediction models.

For more on references and methodology, check out Climate.gov.

This is a guest post by Dr. Aaron Levine who is a National Research Council postdoctoral associate at the NOAA Pacific Marine Environmental Laboratory. His research is on ENSO dynamics and predictability, and focuses on how changes in weather (or what is often referred to as “noise” in climate studies) influence the evolution of ENSO.
Lead reviewer: Michelle L’Heureux, NOAA CPC

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Tweets

BRING IN THE PUMPKINS - It didn't take this family very long to get into the fall spirit, already grabbing pumpkin… https://t.co/twg7nXHMjO

52 minutes ago by WeatherNation

TEXAS FLOODING: Heavy rains are causing big problems in the Lone Star State. #FlashFlooding remains a big threat ac… https://t.co/WQKkfgbcnB

1 hour ago by WeatherNation

Here is the expected path for newly formed Tropical Storm #Kirk. Kirk will be one to watch is it approaches the Car… https://t.co/58ZmTblhFj

2 hours ago by WeatherNation

Florence leftovers could head back to the Carolinas as a much weaker system... Here's what's happening and how the… https://t.co/4x0unMwy1M

2 hours ago by WeatherNation

Tropical Storm Kirk has formed #TSKirk #NHC https://t.co/LlNNrmMj7e

3 hours ago by WeatherNation

NEW VIDEO - Unfortunately it was a busy night for one Texas tow-man as he worked to free several trapped cars caug… https://t.co/GdDH4RzxUx

5 hours ago by WeatherNation

☕ "What is a pumpkin spice latte?" Our lovely morning team is excited to usher in a new season today. Here's wha… https://t.co/FxoiQRdZQC

6 hours ago by WeatherNation

SEVERE WEATHER - Heartbreaking scenes out of Canada after a strong storm ripped through Quebec, leaving behind deva… https://t.co/gXpoj7GmhL

6 hours ago by WeatherNation

Flooding concerns across Texas, Oklahoma and Arkansas this weekend. https://t.co/zu36znzWgj

8 hours ago by WeatherNation

Why Tropical Depression Eleven is expected to weaken as it approaches the Caribbean Sea https://t.co/DyfkcTpt9X

13 hours ago by WeatherNation

SNOW! A Colorado ski area began making snow Friday #cowx @Arapahoe_Basin https://t.co/kNOgkJ71Cd

13 hours ago by WeatherNation

DEMOLISHED NEIGHBORHOODS - Horrific scenes in some neighborhoods in Quebec, Canada as the same system that spawned… https://t.co/t5T8rAGLZE

13 hours ago by WeatherNation

Preliminary reports from the @NWSTwinCities have 5 tornadoes touching down in Minnesota Thursday. Surveys will cont… https://t.co/512xVv3hD4

14 hours ago by WeatherNation

JUST IN: Tropical Depression Eleven has formed east of the Caribbean. The storm is forecast to remain a tropical de… https://t.co/fq0MX6V2UC

15 hours ago by WeatherNation

Beautiful fall foliage is peaking in the Rocky Mountains. These pictures are courtesy Larry Pierce in Steamboat… https://t.co/ur1zzYV25u

15 hours ago by WeatherNation

Updated rainfall reports coming in from parts of Oklahoma are staggering #OKwx https://t.co/06dLB3zmgq

16 hours ago by WeatherNation

FORECAST: Additional rainfall between this afternoon (Friday) and Monday shows up to several *more* inches of rain… https://t.co/EOEwii8A9s

16 hours ago by WeatherNation

Terrifying Sight 👀 A #tornado swept through Gatineau, Quebec in #Canada Friday evening, September 21. The tornado c… https://t.co/K4hxUtdmkn

17 hours ago by WeatherNation
Follow Us